I still find British shows superior to American shows overall. I am a huge science fiction fan sine the tween years, and love supernatural shows as well since I was raised on the original Dark Shadows. I love when a show adds something interesting to the vampire/werewofl/etc. mythology!
I would love for you to add your favorites, this list is a work in progress. I will constantly be updating as I check out more and more recommendations, but I will not add your suggestion if I do not like the show! This is my blog!
Doctor Who, the most recent reincarnation started back up in 2005. Five actors have since played the role. One of the best written science fiction TV show ever.
Being Human was copied for the American audience and was not anywhere near as well done as the original British version with a ghost, werewolf, and vampire living together trying to make a family and save the world!
Primeval, the original British version.
Torchwood is a Doctor Who spin-off, and another favorite of mine!
Wolfblood is an enjoyable werewolf series from Britain.
The Aliens – a modern tale of societal racism, this one is a British version with aliens.
The Sarah Jane Adventures is more for teens, another Doctor Who spin-off.
Humans – the AI have become sentient, and the humans are worried! I loved this show, and it is where I first saw the beautiful Gemma Chan!
Survivors (2008) version) – another plague hits the planet! This is very well done.
Orphan Black (Canadian? British?) I took a long time to try this show, I was nervous that it was too complicated. Instead, I binged this and fell in love with the main actress who showed an incredible acting range.
Hex. Great supernatural show! And the lesbian ghost was in the original Kinky Boots movie playing the shoe manufacturer’s wife!
The Fades – spirits of the dead are all around, if you can see them!
Ghosts is about a haunted castle, but while it has some interesting supernatural angles, it is more of a comedy.
Black Mirror is almost like an updated Twilight Zone series, and it is excellent!
Krypton – this series was on the SYFY network in the US and was fairly well done as a prequel, the story is about Superman’s grandpa as a young man.
ALSO, SOME FOREIGN SHOWS:
Immortals – a Turkish supernatural show which I enjoyed!
Diablero – from Mexico, if you like Demonology.
The 3% from Brazil
The Barrier from Spain
I am always looking for recommendations, and will update this list as I find new shows! Wikipedia has a supernatural series list here!
Please feel free to send your suggestions in the comments!
I am very opinionated and do not like everything. I am also only interested in shows from 2000 and forward, for the most part.